| Matter Hackers I've never tried the comprehensively measure the precision of the SO, but I can tell you that I regularly operate within .002 increments when I'm using it. Id like to see some evidence for what youre saying must happen to the motors by default. We have spent years in our homes creating projects, and learning new software and are here to share our learnings here. james mcbride spouse 6 juin 2022. :P. Ill bet they will eventually support Metric if/when this becomes a common product. Either my math is way off or this very page comes in at ~21MB (!) There are only a few hundredpossible dominos, but thetools computer vision software interprets both the dominoes and their relationship to neighboring dominos. A few users had issues with belt slippage, which can, if not quickly spotted, ruin a project youre working on. Ill admit this is by far the most glowing product endorsement Ive ever seen in a Gerrit article. I'm am a sucker for cool tools so I pre-orderd one anyways. Having used Shapers Origin, theres no tool I want to add to my personal shop more. But as always, Ill wait till the pre-order phase is over and see if the actual product lives up to the hype. The point is, I can store this in my garage, next to my other tools. My comment was praise (for including the interesting backstage stuff), not criticism. Rather than a physical registration it uses a digital method . The tape just does not work in real industrial environment. By moving the magnet closer and furtheraway from the plate they can dynamically adjust the load by inducing eddy currents in the metal. Covert advertising. Come on. shaper claims your average person can do 0.01 with the origin. I think this writer just found his niche in life, especially if he gets paid by the page. Simon Paul liked MeshPoint - wifi router for humanitarian crisis. Thats not a problem with Shaper Origin per se, but more with CNC based routers (note the chess board on their homepage, it doesn't have squares with 90 deg corners). Theres at least one portable gantry device that does this, and thats all it does. Other youtubers have been receiving free units as well all around this time. And I doubt people with this level of skill are driven by the dream of making their living selling tape. No. From that day onward the work is never the same again. #1. I dunno, it looks somewhat like a conventional power tool, so they might grab it. Here we see handles that resemble the ones on the device now. I agree; compare with other sophisticated woodworking tools, and $US2k is not too much. Although Festool strives for accuracy in the website material, the website may contain inaccuracies. As for placing the tape, Origin isnt picky. I dont get it. Its a web-based app: this in itself can put some people off, as you are always at the mercy of Inventables servers. CNC machines can handle 3D relief carving and true V-carving. Shaper could be under a lot of financial stress and unable to meet the demand for many refunds. Keeps them out, keeps me happy.) Check out MatterHackers for the latest promos here. I stand by my review. A CNC is for carving-type items with multiple features, layers, and detail. Theyd also ordered the entire assortment of abrasion coatings offered. As for size & cost, I bought a little gantry machine for $2,200 some years back that has a working area of only 13x24, figuring that it would get me started and Id soon replace it with a larger model. While the Dewalt router that everyone seems to use is fine and dandy;there are hundreds of router spindles out there, and Shaper wanted to find one that would provide the best power, control, quality, and cost to integrate into Origin. Sure, you can go from working on an end table to carving a viking long ship but I dont think many people work on things that big. So first off, this post is much closer to an advertisement than I like to see on HaD. Thanks Leo! Optionally, just type in the dimension of the circle using the onscreen keyboard. Expect to see the Shaper Origin all over the internet this week. The Shapeoko machines do in fact have accessories available. The dust collection system has made a huge difference to most users, with many praising how effective it is. Can you just store that machine on a shelf when its not being used? Your use cases are a bit of a stretch, with the exception of working offsite where Ill grant that the Origin could have a big advantage. It's amazing how little I appreciated learning these skills when I was younger. Everything from the design and layout of the website, to the installation instructions, to the busy forums, to the user-uploaded Projects gallery, is aimed to inspire and inform users. Goliath CNC is a portable CNC machine that defies the way makers, designers, and artisans work on flat surfaces. | Matter Hackers, The Main Differences Between X Carve vs Shapeoko, X-Carve Fully Loaded Kit comes in at around $1,999, Carbide 3D Shapeoko Standard | Matter Hackers, Check out MatterHackers for the latest prices here, 3D Printing for Jewelry: How It Works? Remember all the hype about the Glowforge 3D Laser Printer, another gimmicky product thats in perpetual preorder status? So whats the big deal of spending a few bucks on a reel of duct tape? With the Origin, you have to buy the same router bits AND the fiducial tape, and the tape costs a hell of a lot more than a few bucks. The Origin seems to use template tracing, theyre just digital & youve got some slop built in with the CNC aspect of the tool. The retail price will be $ 2099. Ive fantasized about owning a Shopbot for years, but even if I could afford it, the chances that Id have a place big enough for it are even less. Fortunately Shaper has recently begun posting more videos of the device in action. Its just a toy hobby machine, with real limitations. It needs to stick to a variety of surfaces. You have more than a year until it is shipped. Vibration would make the projector impracticalthe accuracy would be terrible. Like most things that are a big change, the components to build them have been around for a while. When I was done working, that tape came right off as well, again, with no glue, and it had been sitting outside in the driveway getting sun through all that time. https://preorder.shapertools.com/ref/21JHXJAM7. Interesting discussion. Not sure how much I can help you understand but I can see that it wont be that beneficial to a lot of hobby level users. I was leaning Shapeoko but your insight has solidified it for me. Shaper Origin Gen 2 vs 1 First impression J Fred Beck 88 subscribers Subscribe 8.5K views 3 months ago This is an off the cuff, out of the box comparison between the original Shaper. "how accurate is it really?" Bottom Line Up Front Summary: X-Carve is better for those who need a little extra support and/or for something that just WORKS BETTER out of the box. Shaper Origin software has a feature called "helix" which allows you to automatically bore large holes in a single pass using a helical pattern using the router. Not customizable when ordering, shipping announced for July 2015 so its at least 2 months from now. To place a part you simply move and rotate Originuntil the part is oriented properly underneath it on the board Origin works just like a mouse. What it does mean isthat there are no bulky linear motion guides, allowing for a compact device. Efficient, stackable, and safe storage for your tool. I am excited to see what people accomplish with this tool. Theres no need for a 25,000 dollar gantry router to take up half a garage. Another post was really enthusiastic about the new prusa, and i dont see the problem. And if you need to work offsite? OpenCV should be able to do the heavy lifting on position feedback. I saw the Shaper Origin a year later at this year's Connect event and had some time to talk to them and digest. The Shapeoko has everything you need in the box (minus a dust collector), but Carbide does offer a range of bit cutters in different shapes and sizes on their website. All the highlighted dominos are the ones thatOrigin is using to hold its position. Speaking for myself, I get fatigued pretty easily, and could not imagine using the shaper for more than an hour, let alone, three or four or five hours. Both the Shaper Origin and a CNC require learning a lot of software to use it well. Secondly, it offers tons of features for free including V-carving (which you have to pay for with Easel). Its perfectly fine if your mouse accumulates error, because your brain can correct as needed using the information on your monitor *youre* doing the same thing for the mouse as the tape does for the Origin. A machine tool is going to be scraped over its surface multiple times inuse after all. I assume the sidewalk carvers could be adapted to doing carving into wood floors, or even tables and countertops, but youd have to work around the space taken up by the rails and working on things too small for the supports to set on would be a problem. Its absolutely trivial to add more. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Great article but not 100% accurate as of today. Its capacity is more obviously, however it is not a replacement for classic router cnc applications. For most people doing thru hole cuts, I think it would be OK to drive the Z axis by hand using on-screen feedback. Im currently in the process of building a CNC, and its quite some work. you need to think of it as a router with a computer template capacity. Want to increase the capacity? I tend to agree with Daniel. Theres simply too much work. We were kind of blown away by the testing device, but then again these guys are very clever. Were cheaper to repair, and produce new stock from inexpensive carbohydrates. No need for layout tools. What about metric units? Not so with a machine you have to hold in both hands while using it They are just differen machines for differend ways of working. That would be really cool :). For a small (garage) shop this could be a real asset for certain jobs. While moving along the path, the CNC controlled spindle makes minor movements to correct our imperfect human attempts to keep to the line. They are 30-40cm long. No more circle jigs! Originactually has quite a bit of feedback to it. Jeremy Blumthrew together a simple touchscreen control panel that logs spindle metrics in real-time, and allows them to push the spindles until they break. Another problem was that of the spindle. The Best Printers For The Job, How to Find the Best Carbon Fiber 3D Printer. Got one you can send to me (free)? Festool makes no representations about the accuracy, reliability, completeness or timeliness of the material on this website or about the results to be obtained from using the website. Since it is very unlikely that the tape will ever be in the same configuration twice, Origin can use the configuration of the placed tape as a unique identifier for the material. The cut surface will be rugged or lumpy but not straight. Its more likely that thieves will steal all my bikes and leave the tools. The user moves too far from the cut path for Origin to compensate. Is that the case? Only Hackaday has any content that is interesting about a new tool that is interesting to most of us. You can easily do things like layout a pocket for a hidden hinge without ever having to open CAD or vector software. No need to stress about alignment. The Shaper Origin has no theoretical limits on work area. you also can not do 3d contouring. An Arduino drives a floating head with some sandpaper glued to it back and forth. maybe address the most plausible complaints up front? Origin ships with 3 high quality bits. 3/4 Id expect that it would only need a mark placed in the center of the table, easy to measure out with a tape measure, and a second mark X distance from the center along a line perpendicular to one edge of the table. The particular problem areas would be, narrower material, smaller pieces of material, swiss cheese material that you anticipated that you could get a lot of small parts out of yet, edges of material. I know it was big (20m long with material handling), heavy (made of several cm thick steel plate) & Orange. and it doesnt look cheap. Some users reported it took them a few hours from start-to-finish, others took ten or more hours. The content contained on this site is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. But the tone is so enthusiastic that it really looks like some sort of advertorial (publireportage in french), or sponsored post. I see so many uses for this tool SO at the beginning of the article, X-Carve gets the nod as best system, but at the end, the article declares the Shapeoko the best? Weve done 48 without any problem. And when at home, i get to finish the cuts properly. Next, the business wants their logo inlaid into the middle of their floor. It cuts materials such as wood, soft metals, plastics, and composites. Damn. All in all, for what it can do, i dont think 2K is such a ludicrous price. Craftbot Flow Review Is This 3D Printer Worth the Money? Just for fun, what would be the theoretical maximum? Wed sum it up this way our: Most Budget Friendly:Shapeoko is most suitable for those on a tight budget, who want to give CNC-machining a go without spending nearly $2,000 on a machine. It seems ???????????????? It would handily replace my router (that im bad at using), my jigsaw, circular saw, my electric coping saw (i dont know the English name of this tool, scie chantourner) that takes a lot of room, and whose precision in my hands are much lower. Its not a tool that does the work for you,Origin isa tool that makes you better at the work. Check out MatterHackers for the latest promos here. In the end, were all hackers here, and most of us are far from dumb, so even if the product were to end up being bad, or unreliable, thats up to each to think before buying a pricey tool , read actual reviews, articles, and decide weather or not you have enough confidence in the tool to be good enough. Shaper Pro Care is designed for any Origin users who want additional support with Origin. In fact, most of the time, the actual object in question has existed in some form or another for years. Hackaday writers dont review random stuff, they pick things they like and then write an article reviewing them. Slow yes. Were adding this category at the end because we feel it needs extra consideration. However, which one you pick will depend on certain things: how much experience you have, which features matter more to you, and so on. I clicked through all the advertisement videos, and I can tell you this product is total useless for real industrial use. I highly recommend this Seattle based YouTuber. Origin can store a wide array of paths on its internal memory. and how accurate is it really? each one has its strong points and weaknesses. I am still practicing. These are traits that you've come to know Origin for. I get it, and Im excited to see the final product. Shaper Origin is an augmented reality CNC router. the asking price. Get the most out of Origin with access to project plans, learning resources, design support services and more. Im looking forward to the drama in 5 years when half the company splits off to make the Original Origin vs Genuine Origin. https://preorder.shapertools.com/ref/A8JX6BMBW. Lets look at the tech specs to see how it measures up. The Shapeoko 3 CNC Router Kit comes with a wall adapter that can be used to operate the machine at 110-220 V. Conclusion: Shapeoko 3 Review From hardware elements to Carbide Create and Carbide Motion software, almost everything about Shapeoko 3 has been put together keeping the users in mind. That thingy is closed-source, far from cheap, and its usefulness is still to demonstrate (HaD over-positive blog entry sounds fishy at best). Some time ago I worked in a factory which handled a lot of sheet metal and near the end of the last shift we used to load one of the CNC machines with a pallet of sheet metal. Shapeoko 5 Pro is our largest CNC Router. This tool will simplify making quality stuff (signs, templates, etc) since the computer is assisting. Festool makes no representations about the accuracy, reliability, completeness or timeliness of the material on this website or about the results to be obtained from using the website. IWF Challengers Award - 2018. Check the coverage of the tool from the bigger sites. (Comment Policy). And i think id rather pay more, but have my money until i can buy it to have it actually shipped quickly to me. A shaper has a larger motor and spindle. But what happens if someone else starts shipping a superior (or equivalent but less expensive) product eight months from now? Put a book or calculator or something on the mousepad so you can return the mouse to the same physical position. The bits are primarily designed for cutting wood with Origin. The machine mills, cut and engrave any material and interface with various CAD file formats. After a long wait, Shaper has opened up pre-orders for the device. Again, were going to have to give this one to Shapeoko. Both machines are interesting and packed with great features so if you want to get a new hobby, either would be a great choice! Shaper Origin combines computer-guided accuracy with hand-held familiarity. let me just grab the mill from the cabinet.. Or mill the end edge of a 2.4 long shape. A correctly tuned and calibrated (rack and pinion) milling machine should get to a resolution of ~0.075mm to 0.13mm. It also has to be durable. A bit of off-the-shelf watercooling meant for CPUs and the machine can run indefinitely. And it must go back years at this point, and its still not released? And another thing: Your laser optical mouse needs no special tape. It is well priced. Cut a guide on the X-carve, use the guide on the wall with a flush-trim bit? This thing is amazing! If you want the best VALUE for your money, Shapeoko gets you up and running quickly. It takes a lot of tinkering to get the accuracy just right, with users having to pay a lot of attention to the belts in order to improve accuracy. Agree 100% with this. The main differences between X-Carve vs Shapeoko are: Created by the company Inventables, the X-Carve aims its marketing directly at small business owners, advertising how they have helped to transform the lives and businesses of its users, thanks to its relatively low price, ease of use, and free software. This includes your ability to use the tool. The cutting area varies in size depending on the model you choose. Hmm, I would think this one is on par with the othermill article This controls the machines movement by powering stepper motors. Installing any CNC engraving machine can be tricky, which is why Inventables has a detailed step-by-step instruction guide on their website. I dont believe that its possible for anyone (except maybe Superman) to follow a line even remotely accurately by hand. But i'm really not sure if it does actually live up to it's claims and may be more hassle than it's worth with my money better spent elsewhere. Here he is using the actual workpiece as his bed. The unit manages machine-precision with human muscle. Heh, anyone who already has a hernia or back injury for sure. new businesses coming to melbourne, fl But despite that limitation I still see advantages in certain applications. Most gantry routers that are able to cut a full plywood sheet wont cost just 2K. IF in a few years something bad happens and the tape cannot be bought any more then this great tool is useless. There is sometimes insufficient quality or quantity of tape in your workspace. Easel Pro offers even more features for business owners, and the open-source nature of the project allows you to customize your machine even further. A slight change in humidity, and you also eat that up. Shapeoko Pro is a high-performance CNC router in the Shapeoko series. I could barely afford my $20 roll of toilet paper printed with Obamas face! How long you going to hold up before your back starts screaming at you and you develop eyestrain? Copyright 2023 l Total3DPrinting l A Venture 4th Media Company. Not as intrigued as many but I have changed from from an early implementor or purchaser. BCN3D Epsilon W50 Review: Worth the Price? If you don't know what the Shaper Origin is you can see it here: https://shapertools.com/. nsker du at komme p kursus, s kontakt personalet. Very. Both have their place. It will not replace any working cnc router or mill. From the free web app, Easel, to the huge online Projects area to give their users inspiration, its designed to make it easy to quickly create new products to sell. Its tempting to boil it down and say that its a CNC machine, or a router. Frankly, its a chore to avoid, moving the X-Carve. Its not an incremental change, its a change. Crikey, get over it! I do like the X-Carve but I went with Shapeoko in the end. X-Carve can be customized if youre an experienced and avid CNC user with a variety of add-ons, whereas the Shapeoko comes as one unit with no add-ons, X-Carve comes with a dust collector, whereas Shapeoko is a lot cheaper, X-Carve is a cloud-based software, whereas Shapeoko is a software that can be installed onto your PC or Mac, X-Carve software has some features locked behind a paid plan, whereas Shapekos free software contains all the features upfront, X-Carve takes a long time to install, whereas Shapeoko comes part-installed, Customizable great if youre an experienced user, Software is pretty straightforward to learn (approachable learning curve), 2017 update has fixed a lot of issues that users had previously, The machine works well and at a good speed, The online community of users is a nice bonus, It can take a lot of adjusting to get to maximum accuracy, The software is great and has everything you need for free, Performance is good with especially smooth results when using wood, Takes some adjusting to get the accuracy just right. Drop an android/iphone on a 3d printed mount (on an existing router) and use the integrated camera for the machine vision and positioning. An industrial ink jet head would print a continuous pattern on a carefully reeled spool of tape. An operator can cut pockets for cabinet hardware with an excellent degree of accuracy or add an engraved detail to an appliance panel. The CNC machine uses a drill bit and multi-directional wheels and can automatically measure the size of the material you are cutting.