We briefly consider federal requirements governing research ethics in Chapter 6, where we argue for a federal education research agency to take a leading role in facilitating ethical access to student data. An organization has specific goal or purposes for its existence. Another way that some field-based researchers have recently attempted to bring educational practice closer to the research process is by embedding inquiry in sites of practice (National Research Council, 2001a). Because of this, many current educational reformssuch as school-to-work partnerships between schools and employersare directed toward enhancing the connection between secondary school curricula and labor market opportunities. In addition, many educational organizations, such as the National School Climate Center . the development of professional training for education researchers particularly vexing. More subtly, but crucially, these values also affect the choice of outcomes to study and measure, as they are proxies for the myriad goals of education: basic knowledge and skills, community service, job training, social development, and problem solving. Despite the existence of various studies on different types of leadership and educational change, educational change theory needs further development to bring deep educational reform. Also operative are market competition, bureaucratic power, professional authority, and ideological formation (Weiss 1990). Teachers College Record 100:513535. Theory in the social sciences is predictive, but more often it serves to understand things that happened in the past, serving a more diagnostic or explanatory purpose. This variation can be usefully categorized along three axes: control, degrees and programs offered, and student-body composition. The current education reform movement can be traced back 18 years ago to the report of a Presidential commission, A Nation at Risk (National Commission on Excellence in Education, 1983). 0
This is evident in the words of the highly influential 1918 report, Cardinal Principles of Secondary Education: "The comprehensive school is the prototype of a democracy in which various groups have a degree of self-consciousness as groups and yet are federated into a larger whole through the recognition of common interests and ideals. Citizens elect local school boards and frequently vote on budgets, property tax rates, and bond issues. In William H. Clune and John F. Witte, eds., Choice and Control in AmericanEducation, vol. New York: Pergamon. This strategy is often used in medical trials to ensure that researchers perspectives are not influenced by their knowledge of which participants received which treatment, and similarly, that this knowledge does not alter the behavior of the research participants. Nations with strongly centralized school governance leave much less room for local control and therefore for local variation in the content and structure of schooling. The main fount of professional authority lies in the fact that effective teaching requires the exercise of discretionhow teachers are to interact with students cannot be prescribedand teachers largely monopolize the knowledge necessary to correctly exercise that discretion. They create jobs and define their responsibilities, establish organizational rules, allocate scarce resources (money, space, staff, etc. hbbd``b` $> j$X 6DS = V($.L CDg\ B
7
The majority of teachers are women, giving teaching less status than more male-dominated professions. Assertions of bureaucratic authority have been met by counterclaims by teachers in the name of professional authority or market control. Hence, school districts compete to hire and retain teachers, particularly if they are in fields such as math and science, where qualified teachers are scarce. It often does not end up benefiting the students to which it is ostensibly targeted (Somini 1999). Its main limitation is that it usually takes a long time to establish. Goodlad, John 1984 A Place Called School: Prospects for theFuture. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Very frequently they vote on who will represent them on a school board or in state office. McPherson & Jacobson, L.L.C., Executive Recruitment and Development, in collaboration with the . Economically Advanced Countries. In general, institutional elements such as conformity to institutional rules, isomorphism, decou-pling, and loose coupling argued to prevail in schools seem to be obstacles for many educational. http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v7n1z. In James G. March, ed., Handbook of Organizations. Since about 1970, most urban school systems have introduced a wide variety of programs in order to meet demands for more choice, retain middle-class white students, and better motivate students (Dougherty and Sostre 1992). With such expectations, it will become increasingly easy to establish the relationshipsweak or strongthat are critical for conducting education research. The movement for school-based management has given teachers the potential to exercise greater power over how schools are run, though it is still not clear to what extent this has become a reality. The United States and Germany are nearly polar opposite on virtually all these dimensions. Mirroring the diversity of the broader population, education takes place in specific neighborhoods with their particular geographical, historical, social, ethnic, linguistic, economic, and cultural mixes. In the section that follows we discuss some of the salient features of education and their effects on scientific research: values and politics; human volition; variability in education programs; the organization of schools; and the diversity of the many individuals involved in education. They can receive student financial aid, grants to build academic facilities, and grants and contracts to conduct research and run academic programs. 1990; Kerchner et al. Because they draw from neighborhoods differing in class and racial composition, they end up differing from each other in student composition. Market Competition. In such naturalistic research paradigms (Moschkovich and Brenner, 2000), investigators do not seek to distance themselves from research participants, but rather to immerse themselves in the participants lives, with conscious attention to how the investigator affects and contributes to the research process. and contribute knowledge about it. The nearly 700 "general baccalaureate" or "liberal arts" colleges emphasize undergraduate education and have very few, if any, graduate programs. For one thing, business controls jobs. Education Management Organizations and Their Unique Features Begun in the early 1990s, EMOs continue to grow today, now serving more than 350,000 students across 31 states.3 In this article I specifically address the largest, for-profit EMOs in the country, namely those managed by Focused on advances lasting solutions to improve learning, Education Development Center has been a leader since 1958 . entrance exams also may complicate the evaluation of the effectiveness of curricular change. 4 Features of Education and Education Research, 6 Design Principles for Fostering Science in a Federal Education Research Agency, Appendix: Biographical Sketches, Committee Members and Staff. If many middle-class students desert a school district, it loses state funding, which is largely enrollment-driven. The jury is still out on whether they will enroll more than a fraction of public school students, successfully "routinize the charisma" of their founders after those founders move on, significantly enhance the performance of their students, and effectively stimulate regular public schools to improve. Schools compete to place their students in good jobs because a good placement record can be used in turn to attract students. Human movement and change have, for example, affected efforts to study the effects of education vouchers on student achievement. The dual purposes of education research suggest that there must be a balance of considerations of the factors of the validity of the knowledge claims, the credibility of the. It used to be that the main choices parents had available were between sending their children to public or private schools or between living in one school district versus another. For example, in Africa, the ratio of secondary school students to the secondary-age population ranges from 7 percent in Mozambique to 77 percent in Egypt (U.S. National Center for Education Statistics 1997). For example: "All students have the potential to succeed," or "Teaching is a team sport." This absence of scrutiny may be due to the weakness of the socialist tradition in the United States. New York: Harper and Row. But it will take many years of such efforts before the United States even approximates Germany or Japan in the closeness of linkage between school and work. Researchers, historians, and philosophers of science have debated the nature of scientific research in education for more than 100 years. These include: diffuse and intangible goals; value sensitivity; high cost and external dominance; client service and client dependence; obstacles to output measurements; professionalization and feminization. 1990 "Control in School Organizations: Theoretical Perspectives." observer, involved with the experience and action of those observed (Blumer, 1966; Denzin, 1978; Kelly and Lesh, 2000). Public discussion and the public interest tend to be seen as no more relevant to voting than to buying. Implementation system features are: organization of small symmetric subunits; organizational implications of goal conflict; compulsory attendance of clients; cognitive vs. emotive functions; resulting tensions and conflicts; subcultures; clients' vulnerability; differential treatment of clients; obstacles to output measurement; and implication of measurement difficulties. But political authority is only one of several, often contradictory, mechanisms of influence over U.S. schooling. Schools use a diverse set of ICT tools to communicate, create, disseminate, store, and manage information. Organizational decisions are recorded through explicit and voluminous records. But they do all this within parameters set by the national ministry, which can veto their decisions (Kanaya 1994). Brint, Steven 1998 Schools and Society. But because many disciplines are focusing on different parts of the system, contradictory conclusions may be offered, adding fuel to the debates about both the specific topic and the value of education research. And unlike the other forms of power, it is particularly dependent on the willing acquiescence of those who would be influenced (Weiss 1990). 3. culture-type organizations, which have a moral-normative pattern and are Simply put, researchers need practitioners and practitioners need researchers. Formal schooling takes place in an interdependent, multilayered system. However, within many of these schools, there are "academies" or other magnet programs, which are operationally independent and have some freedom to select their students from wider attendance areas. In addition to different tracks, most U.S. urban school districts maintain specialized vocational and academic secondary schools. New York: Basic Books. Meanwhile, graduates of the Gymnasium go on to take the Abitur exam, which determines if they will be allowed into university. There is no defining definition of educational management because its development has drawn heavily on several disciplines like economics, political science and sociology. Virtually all societies utilize all three forms of education, but they differ in the relative predominance of these forms. They also exercise direct democratic control by voting on tax rates and bond issues through local and state referenda and initiative elections. 3 Guiding Principles for Scientific Inquiry, 5 Designs for the Conduct of Scientific Research in Education, The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. In studying the effectiveness of an educational program, then, comparisons must almost always be made to standard or existing practice. All human organizations are complex and one way of understanding their characteristics is through complexity theory. Define It. In Philip G. Altbach, ed., International Higher Education: An Encyclopedia, vol. While the Scholastic Assessment Test (SAT) and the American College Testing (ACT) exam are widely used, they are privately operated and individual colleges decide whether and how their results will be used. They try to ensure that both mentors, students, employees, managers, and everyone involved in their organization feel safe and comfortable. The Educational Forum 44 (May):483490. By identifying your organization's specific focus, goals, resources and processes for addressing growth, you will be positioned. Wells, Amy Stuart 1993 Time to Choose. Education and schooling are not synonymous. In this situation, the comparative effect of a new intervention will rarely be large when compared with the standard practice. While small in numbers and enrollments, the elite private schools, which are variously termed "prep" or "boarding" or "country day" schools, carry great prestige and importance. 82 0 obj
<>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<73D93B1446426F4486D3CAD8CA01DB72><43456FABDE7D654C87AA592336A53EF8>]/Index[65 35]/Info 64 0 R/Length 88/Prev 173434/Root 66 0 R/Size 100/Type/XRef/W[1 2 1]>>stream
Academy of Management Journal, 34, 487-516. School district boundaries are usually coterminous with local political boundaries, but elected school boards are rarely identified with a political party. Phi DeltaKappan (February):448454. are examples of such organizations. And when we turn to control of the U.S. system, we need to look beyond political authority to also consider other, often contradictory, mechanisms of influence over the schools: market competition, bureaucratic decision making, professional authority, and ideological formation. In 1995 about 61 percent of three- to five- year-olds were enrolled part time or full time in nursery schools or kindergartens (U.S. National Center for Educational Statistics 1997). All rights reserved. Click here to buy this book in print or download it as a free PDF, if available. In addition, within classrooms, students are often placed into different instructional groups based on instructional needs or related issues. 66 1 All About Education Industry: Key Segments, Trends and Competitive Advantages The Education Industry comprises establishments whose primary objective is to provide education. Educational Features. But other factors also play an important role in causing this variation. In fact, business's influence based on its role as future employer of students has been institutionalized in the form of a myriad of business/school or school-to-work "compacts" or "partnerships" in which formal links are established and schools receive resources and job placements in return for greater responsiveness to business opinions about the desirable content of education (Gelberg 1997; Van Horn 1995). Schools can refuse to act in the way a market actor wishes, but that actor achieves compliance by supplying or denying resources that the school values and that the school cannot easily acquire from alternative sources (Pfeffer and Salancik 1978). 11 No. Children of lower socioeconomic status (SES) groups tend to perform worse in school, Charter Schools For example, charter schoolspublic schools that operate under contract with either a state agency or a local school boardtake very different forms according to their states authorizing statutes and the particular contracts (charters) under which the schools operate (RPP International, 2000). Economically Less Developed Countries. Albany: State University of New York Press. Therefore, its best to use Encyclopedia.com citations as a starting point before checking the style against your school or publications requirements and the most-recent information available at these sites: http://www.chicagomanualofstyle.org/tools_citationguide.html. Interestingly, there has been little conflict between market control and democratic authority. 1993; Mohrman et al. Oakes, Jeannie, and Martin Lipton 1992 "Detracking Schools: Early Lessons from the Field." Ballantine, Jeanne H. 1997 The Sociology of Education:A Systematic Analysis. Ethical issues also have implications for data collection. And because of this variation and their youth, it is unclear what impact charter schools will ultimately have. Political scientists study the implementation of large-scale institutional change, like charter schools. They have explicit goals. Education researchers have long investigated the interrelationship of these various levels of the system. This research is carried out in a collaboration in which district and school personnel have vested interests in the research. A specific implication of the role of contextual factors in education research is that the boundaries of generalization from scientific research need to be carefully delineated. Therefore, that information is unavailable for most Encyclopedia.com content. Rather, they specialize in undergraduate, master's, and law programs. These differences demand that researchers consider the nature of the vertical organization of the system in their work. 1986 Different by Design: Politics, Purpose, andPractice in Three Magnet Schools. Economically less developed countries (LDCs) vary greatly as well in the size and structure of their school systems. , and Jeannie Oakes 1996 "Potential Pitfalls of Systemic Reform: Early Lessons from Detracking Research." Most online reference entries and articles do not have page numbers. The boards also vote on the school budget, the local tax rate (though usually subject to voter referendum), curriculum, teaching, facilities standards beyond state minimal, and the rules for hiring and supervising teachers (Campbell et al. Even within reform movements, the state and local control of education significantly shapes the ways that instructional programs and other changes to schooling are implemented, making generalizations difficult. We argue that a key implication of these features of education is the need to account for influential contextual factors within the process of inquiry and in understanding the extent to which findings can be generalized. Once granted a "charter" by the state or other designated authority, these schools operate independently of many existing school regulations but are financed by funds that would otherwise go to the districts. Robert D O'Keefe Lawrence O Hamer & Philip R Kemp Characteristics of a " Teaching Institution": Administrative Objectives, Actions, Activities and Assessment 70 Fall 01 Volume Issue ) Journal of Academic Administration in Higher Education 71 by doing so, avoiding, as much as possible, any contact with undergraduate students (Collier 2013). Mohrman, Susan Albers, and Priscilla Wohlstetter 1994 School Based Management. Even the comprehensive public high schools provide alternatives within their walls in the form of different curricular groupings (college prep, vocational, and general) and courses at different levels of rigor. They include demand for mass character of creative competences acquisition, determining focus of teaching on individualization, recognition of high value of talent, organization of lifetime education. (Hebrew University of Jerusalem) and Ed.M. Instead, schooling in the United States is a state and local responsibility. foster cognitive and emotional growth; and sort and select students into different categoriescollege . Although one cannot predict exactly when they will occur, awareness of them permits teachers to interpret student comments more effectively and to create assessment items to test for evidence of them. Weiss, Janet A. Their work is done through a division of labor involving specialized jobs. Because values are so deeply embedded in education in so many different ways, education researchers do not have a singular practical goal that drives their inquiry (Bruner, 1996). Similarly, categorical aid often fails to accomplish its purpose. Show this book's table of contents, where you can jump to any chapter by name. For example, the social and cultural work of sociologists and cultural anthropologists often do not lend themselves to the controlled conditions, randomized treatments, or repeated measures that typify investigations in physics or chemistry. Ideological Formation. 1990; Wirt and Kirst 1992). Further, new initiatives often require a significant commitment of funds for professional development, which may or may not be available. Recent enthusiasm for "evidence-based" policy and practice in educationnow codified in the federal law that authorizes the bulk of elementary and secondary education programshave brought a new sense of urgency to understanding the ways in which the basic tenets of science manifest in the study of teaching, learning, and schooling. Paris, France: Author. Given their number, it is not surprising that American colleges are quite varied. The volition, or will, of these individuals decreases the level of control that researchers can have over the process. endstream
endobj
66 0 obj
<>
endobj
67 0 obj
<>
endobj
68 0 obj
<>stream
They include demand for mass character of creative competences acquisition, determining focus of teaching on individualization, recognition of high value of talent, organization of lifetime education. ), order specific actions, referee conflicts among subordinates, and hire and supervise subordinates (Campbell et al. Meanwhile, about 2,000 colleges are private, owned either by religious groups, profit-making corporations, or nonsectarian, non-profit-making boards. The governance of education has been a repeated motif in our discussion above. However, the date of retrieval is often important. People and organizational culture: A profile comparison approach to assessing person-organization fit. The challenge for the diverse field of education is to integrate theories and empirical findings across domains and methods. Students from immigrant families are often defined by a characteristic they commonly sharea lack of English fluency. If the technology is not educationally effective, why would you use it? Even economically advanced societies differ greatly in how their school systems are governed and how their students' school careers are structured. But it is not just the public/private divide that provides differentiation within the U.S. system. New York City also has a variety of vocational schools. The U.S. Department of Education distinguishes five kinds of colleges according to the degrees and programs that they offer. National and international school reform initiatives i, Educational Institutions and Philosophies, Traditional and Modern, Educational Foundation for Women in Accounting, Educational Broadcasting, Federal Support, Education: Primary Public EducationNational Schools from 1831, Education: Primary Private Education"Hedge Schools" and Other Schools, Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, https://www.encyclopedia.com/social-sciences/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/educational-organization. In fact, market control over public schooling is steadily rising with the current vogue for school choice, charter schools, performance-based funding, and other means of making public schools more "accountable.". Moreover, textbook writers and publishers, who provide instructional material for schools nationwide, influence what is taught and often how it is taught by marketing the same instructional materials nationwide (Apple 1986). Like others we discuss in this chapter, these typical circumstances require that researchers be careful to specify caveats and conditions under which findings are produced. In addition, LDCs vary greatly in how socially exclusive their higher education systems are; for example, in 1985 the proportion of postsecondary students who are female ranged from 24 percent in sub-Saharan Africa to 52 percent in the Caribbean (Ramirez and Riddle 1991). They offer graduate programs but graduate few people with doctoral or medical degrees. You're looking at OpenBook, NAP.edu's online reading room since 1999. Whitty, Geoff, Sally Power, and David Halpin 1998 Devolution and Choice in Education: The School, theState, and the Market. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution. Evaluations of changes in curriculum are also influenced by variability in programs. To be sure, seventeen U.S. states do use minimum-competency examinations for awarding high school degrees (Airasian 1987; U.S. National Center for Education Statistics 1997), but the country still does not have a European-style national examination that alone determines university entrance. However legitimate and powerful political authority is, it can also be ineffective, particularly in a highly decentralized political system such as that of the United States. New Leaders Council. Educational management, the name implies, operates in the educational organizations. Encyclopedia of Sociology. New York Times (February 23):B1, B5. In addition, business along with foundations and government influence schools through discretionary funding. 1. This linguistic diversity that characterizes many U.S. schools illustrates the influence of diversity on research. Political authority is vested in the various elected bodies of government and ultimately in the citizenry. The need for care and oversight when studying vulnerable populations like children sometimes entails justifiable compromises in the conduct of scientific study and the progress of the scientific enterprise more generally. Parents may refuse to allow their children to participate in a study because of privacy. The operation of public education at the elementary and secondary levels largely rests with the local school district. Pick a style below, and copy the text for your bibliography. The problems with conducting randomized trials attest to this fact: there is little expectation that educational programs or interventions should be subjected to rigorous research (Cook 2001; Burtless, in press). MyNAP members SAVE 10% off online. There are several countries that lodge governance primarily at the subnational or provincial level, such as the United States, Canada, and Germany. However, this phenomenon, typically termed "tracking," has been criticized as a significant source of class and racial inequality in educational attainment (Dougherty 1996). Apple, Michael 1986 Teachers and Texts. Finally, the high geographic mobility of students and teachers has helped reduce the isolation and consequent diversity among schools. A perspective of education research as an enterprise points to some of the infrastructure supports that sustain it, a topic we take up in our consideration of the federal role in supporting education research (Chapter 6). Cultural anthropologists study the character and form of social interactions that characterize students formal and informal educational experiences. So far, in our discussion of control we have focused on political authority, whether exercised by national, state, or local governments or the citizens that elect them. Yet school systems still differ considerably, even among countries comparable in economic development. The strong local role in educational governance in the U.S. system makes it more likely that the demands of non-college-goers will be listened to. Phenomena such as language socialization, deviancy, the development of an idea, or the interaction of cultural tradition with educational instruction are notoriously impervious to the controls used in the systematic investigations of atoms or molecules. The last section points out some implications of the analysis which seem to indicate similar and increasingly important developments in other public service bureaucracies.